Pressure pulsation creates significant challenges across various industrial applications. Left unchecked, these oscillations can lead to excessive vibration, noise, reduced efficiency, and even catastrophic equipment failure.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the causes and consequences of pressure pulsation in the machinery industry. We’ll then explore proven solutions and best practices to mitigate these issues, helping you optimize your systems for peak performance and reliability.
What is Pressure Pulsation
Pressure pulsation is a periodic fluctuation in pressure that occurs in fluid systems, particularly those with pumps, compressors, or turbines. These pressure variations are superimposed on the steady operating pressure of the system and can range from a few millibars to several bars in amplitude.
Pressure pulsations are distinct from steady-state pressure changes or pressure surges. Steady-state changes are relatively slow, gradual variations in the overall system pressure. Pressure surges, on the other hand, are sudden, high-amplitude spikes caused by events like valve closures or pump startups. While surges are transient events, pulsations are ongoing oscillations that persist as long as the causing mechanism (e.g., a pump) is operating.
Causes of Pressure Pulsation
Reciprocating Pumps and Compressors
One of the most common causes of pressure pulsation is the use of reciprocating pumps and compressors. These devices operate by displacing fluid through the cyclical motion of pistons or plungers. As the piston moves back and forth, it creates alternating suction and discharge phases, leading to inherent fluctuations in flow and pressure.
Positive Displacement Pumps
Positive displacement pumps, including gear pumps, screw pumps, and vane pumps, can also contribute to pressure pulsation. These pumps trap and move discrete volumes of fluid, which can result in flow ripples and pressure variations, especially at the pump’s discharge.
Pipe Layout
Abrupt changes in pipe diameter, such as expansions or contractions, can cause flow disturbances and pressure fluctuations. Long, straight pipe runs may allow pulsations to propagate and amplify, while bends and elbows can reflect pressure waves, leading to interference patterns. The location and spacing of pipe supports and anchors can also affect the system’s response to pulsation.
Pressure Vessels and Tanks
Pressure vessels and tanks in the system can interact with the pulsating flow, either amplifying or attenuating the pulsations. When the pulsation frequency matches the natural frequency of the vessel or tank, resonance can occur, leading to excessive vibration and potential damage.
Turbulence and Vortex Shedding
As fluid flows past obstructions or through complex geometries, it can create localized eddies and vortices that shed periodically. These flow instabilities generate fluctuating forces on the pipe walls, leading to pressure pulsations.
Water Hammer (Rapid Valve Closure)
Rapid valve closure or pump startup/shutdown can trigger a phenomenon known as water hammer. When a moving fluid is suddenly forced to stop or change direction, it creates a pressure wave that travels through the system at the speed of sound. This pressure surge can be several times higher than the normal operating pressure, potentially causing severe damage to pipes, valves, and other components.
Changes in Flow Direction/Velocity
Any abrupt change in flow direction or velocity can generate pressure pulsations. This can occur at pipe bends, tees, or reducers where the fluid is forced to alter its course or speed. The resulting flow disturbances create localized pressure fluctuations that can propagate through the system.
Resonance
Resonance occurs when the frequency of the pressure pulsations matches the natural frequency of the piping system or its components. Under resonant conditions, the pulsations can be amplified significantly, leading to excessive vibration, noise, and potential structural damage. The risk of resonance is higher in systems with long, unsupported pipe spans, low damping, or a coincidence between the excitation frequency and the acoustic or structural natural frequencies.
Fluid Properties
The properties of the fluid being transported can also influence pressure pulsation behavior. Key fluid characteristics include:
- Density: Higher-density fluids have greater inertia, which can result in more pronounced pressure fluctuations when subjected to flow disturbances.
- Viscosity: High-viscosity fluids tend to dampen pressure pulsations due to their increased resistance to flow and ability to dissipate energy.
- Compressibility: Compressible fluids, such as gases, are more susceptible to pressure pulsations compared to incompressible liquids. The compressibility allows pressure waves to propagate more easily and can lead to higher pulsation amplitudes.
Consequences of Uncontrolled Pressure Pulsation
Vibration
Excessive vibration is one of the most common outcomes of uncontrolled pressure pulsation. The fluctuating pressure waves can induce mechanical vibrations in pipes, valves, and other components. These vibrations not only contribute to increased wear and tear on the equipment but also pose risks to the structural integrity of the system.
Noise
Pressure pulsation often manifests as audible noise, particularly in systems with high flow velocities or rapid pressure changes. The turbulence and cavitation generated by the pulsating flow can create a range of noise frequencies, from low rumbles to high-pitched whistles.
Efficiency Loss
The energy associated with the pulsating flow is essentially wasted, as it does not contribute to the desired fluid transfer. This energy loss manifests as increased power consumption by pumps and compressors, leading to higher operating costs. Additionally, the turbulence and flow disruptions caused by the pulsation can reduce the effectiveness of heat exchangers, filters, and other process equipment, further compromising the system’s efficiency.
Equipment Damage
Perhaps the most severe consequence of uncontrolled pressure pulsation is the potential for equipment damage. The repeated stress cycles imposed by the fluctuating pressure can lead to accelerated wear and premature failure of various components:
- Seals, Gaskets, and Gauges: The cyclic loading can cause seals and gaskets to degrade faster, resulting in leaks and loss of system integrity. Pressure gauges and other instrumentation may also suffer damage from the pulsating pressure, leading to inaccurate readings or complete failure.
- Erosion: The turbulent flow patterns associated with pressure pulsation can accelerate erosion, particularly in areas with sudden changes in flow direction or velocity. Over time, this erosion can thin pipe walls, create leaks, and even lead to ruptures.
- Cavitation: In severe cases of pressure pulsation, localized pressure drops can cause the formation and collapse of vapor bubbles, known as cavitation. The implosion of these bubbles generates high-intensity shock waves that can erode and pit surfaces, causing significant damage to impellers, valves, and other components.
- Pipeline Rupture: In extreme scenarios, the combined effects of vibration, erosion, and fatigue induced by pressure pulsation can lead to pipeline ruptures.
Solutions
Pulsation Dampeners
Pulsation dampeners are devices designed to reduce pressure fluctuations in fluid systems. They typically consist of a gas-charged bladder or diaphragm inside a pressure vessel. As the fluid pressure increases, the gas compresses, absorbing the pressure spike. When the pressure drops, the gas expands, maintaining a more constant downstream pressure.
Pulsation dampeners are installed close to the pulsation source, such as a pump discharge or near a valve, to minimize the transmission of pulsations through the system.
Surge Suppressors
Surge suppressors, also known as shock arrestors or water hammer arrestors, are designed to absorb sudden pressure spikes associated with water hammer events. During a rapid valve closure, the suppressor allows a limited fluid flow into an expansion chamber, cushioning the pressure surge.
Surge suppressors are typically installed at pipe endpoints and near quick-closing valves.
Staggered Vane Impellers
For centrifugal pumps, using impellers with staggered vanes can help reduce pressure pulsations. In a conventional impeller, vanes are evenly spaced, causing pressure pulses as each vane passes the volute tongue. By staggering the vanes at uneven intervals, the pressure pulses are distributed more evenly, reducing the overall pulsation amplitude.
Staggered vane impellers are most effective in reducing pulsations at the pump’s blade pass frequency. They do not eliminate pulsations entirely but can significantly reduce vibration and noise issues.
Pump Design
Oversized pumps operating far from their best efficiency point (BEP) are more prone to flow instabilities and pulsations. Selecting a pump that operates close to its BEP at the desired flow rate can help reduce pulsations.
For positive displacement pumps, using multiple smaller pumps in parallel rather than a single large pump can help reduce pulsation amplitude. Triplex pumps tend to have lower pulsation than simplex or duplex designs due to smoother flow delivery.
Alternative Approaches
In some cases, pulsation can be mitigated through simple changes to the piping system:
- Orifice Plates: Installing an orifice plate downstream of the pulsation source introduces a pressure drop that can help dissipate pulsation energy.
- Flexible Hoses and Expansion Joints: Using flexible connections close to the pulsation source can help isolate vibrations from the rest of the piping system. Expansion joints accommodate pipe movement and thermal growth which could otherwise lead to high stresses and failures.
Operational Adjustments
In addition to hardware solutions, adjusting system operation can help manage pressure pulsations:
- Pump Speed Control: Running pumps at lower speeds reduces pulsation frequency and amplitude. Variable frequency drives allow pumps to operate at reduced speeds during low demand periods.
- Multi-Pump Phasing: For multi-pump installations, adjusting the phase angle between pumps so that their pulsations are out of sync can help minimize downstream pulsation.
English 
Korean 
German 
Italian 
Spanish 
French 
Japanese