Machine lapping runs a batch of seal faces at once in conditioning rings on a rotating plate under a set load, while hand lapping moves one face at a time across a stationary plate, so its result depends on the plate’s wear and the operator’s pressure. The machine is the method for steady volume, hard faces and flatness that repeats from face to face. Hand lapping suits a few faces, mostly carbon, touched up close to the pump.

What Is Hand Lapping

Hand lapping is rubbing a seal face over a flat lapping plate charged with abrasive paste until the wear track is gone and the face reads flat under an optical flat. Everything it needs fits in a case: a cast-iron or glass plate, a tube of compound, an optical flat and a monochromatic light, so it can be done beside the pump.

What Is Machine Lapping

Machine lapping places seal faces, lapping side down, inside rings that sit on a rotating plate, and lets the plate and rings turn the faces through an abrasive slurry until they are flat. The machine has four working parts:

  • Lapping plate: a rotating table, usually of soft cast iron, that carries the abrasive.
  • Conditioning rings: three or four rings that hold the faces and rotate as the plate turns, spreading wear across the plate so it stays flat longer.
  • Abrasive slurry: dry abrasive mixed with light oil and fed onto the plate as the job runs, replacing worn grit.
  • Weight: a pressure plate set on the faces inside a ring when their own weight is not enough.

The Difference Between Hand and Machine Lapping

A machine sets the plate condition, the load and the motion that hand lapping leaves to the operator.

Flatness

Both methods can bring a face to the flatness a seal drawing calls for. A hand-lapped face is only as flat as the plate was that day and as even as the operator’s pressure.

Hard Face Materials

Silicon carbide, tungsten carbide and alumina ceramic faces suit a machine: by hand, stock comes off them slowly even with diamond compound, while carbon laps easily. On a machine, that slow removal is a matter of load and cycle time, with no operator holding each face.

Repeatability and Throughput

A machine laps several faces at once in each conditioning ring and gives each face in the batch the same plate, load and motion. Hand lapping does one face at a time.

Cost

Hand lapping costs little to set up and a lot per face in skilled labour. A machine costs far more up front and less per face, so it pays for itself only with steady volume, and it has running costs of its own: abrasive slurry, plate reconditioning and the time to train an operator.

How to Choose the Right One

Hand lap a few lightly worn faces, mostly carbon, when the pump has to be back the same day; send everything else to a machine, your own or a seal shop’s.

Neither method saves a face with deep damage. Generic flat lapping normally leaves only 0.0005 to 0.005 in of stock to remove, so a face with chips, heat checking or scoring deeper than that needs grinding first or a new face.

A face that still fails the flatness check after hand lapping should go to a machine, once the common lapping problems such as a worn plate or contaminated compound are ruled out.

Some seals should go to a qualified seal shop whichever method you own. Faces with hydrodynamic grooves or a deliberately shaped profile lose the shape they were designed with if lapped flat, and a seal certified for explosive atmospheres must perform exactly as its documentation states after repair.