Thermal shock cracks a ceramic seal face when the face changes temperature faster than heat can move through the ring, most often when cool liquid reaches a face that has been running hot: the surface shrinks against a hotter core, goes into tension and cracks.
You identify it by cracks with no contact mark at their origin and an operating event just before the leak. You prevent it by slowing the temperature change at the face and fitting a face material that tolerates the changes the duty cannot avoid.
How Thermal Shock Cracks a Ceramic Face
A fast temperature change cracks a ceramic face because the surface and the core of the ring are briefly at different temperatures, and a ceramic cannot yield to relieve the stress that difference sets up. When cool liquid hits a hot face, the surface tries to shrink against the hotter core and goes into tension, and a crack opens once that tension reaches the ceramic’s tensile strength.
A face shrink-fitted or pressed into a metal holder carries a second stress. Holder metals expand more per degree than ceramic and carbon faces, so a fast temperature swing changes the interference fit, and the changed fit can distort or fracture the ring.
What Triggers Thermal Shock in a Seal
The most frequent trigger is cool liquid reaching a face that has overheated, usually after dry running or on a low-lubricity fluid. In pump operation that happens in a few recurring ways:
- Liquid returns after a dry run: a pump that ran dry on startup, on a drained suction or on vapour reprimes and floods faces that heated up without lubrication.
- A lost flush comes back: an external flush that tripped or was shut off while the pump kept running is restored at its normal temperature onto faces that ran hot in the meantime.
- Process swings: a product change or cleaning cycle switches the liquid at the faces from hot to cold in one step.
- Hot liquid into a cold pump: the reverse direction, when hot product is introduced into a pump that was not warmed. It cracks faces less often than sudden cooling does, but it can still fracture them.
How to Recognise Thermal Shock on a Failed Face
Thermal shock leaves cracks that start at the surface the liquid cooled, with no contact mark at their origin, on a face that went through a cooling or heating event just before it started to leak. Sudden cooling often leaves a network of shallow surface cracks that does not run through the ring, so a shocked face can be cracked and leaking while the ring is still in one piece.
Radial cracks are among the most common marks on a damaged seal face, and on their own they do not identify thermal shock. Find where the crack starts first, then check the operating history for a dry run, a flush trip and restart, a startup on hot product or a product change.
Thermal Shock or Heat Checking
Heat checking is cracking from the seal’s own frictional heat while it runs; thermal shock is cracking from one sudden change in the temperature of the liquid around the face. Heat checks form under poor lubrication, high speed or high face load, sit in the running track and build up over running hours.
On a ceramic face the two can look alike, because overheating also produces radial cracks, radial cracks with blisters and surface crazing. Separate them by what the face went through: a duty with marginal lubrication and cracking confined to the contact band point to heat checking, and a single cold-liquid event before the failure points to thermal shock.
Thermal cycling, in which the face temperature rises and falls repeatedly while the seal runs, belongs with heat checking.
Thermal Shock or Impact Damage
An impact or installation crack starts at a point of contact, and that point usually leaves a mark. Look for a chip, a crushed spot with small fragments missing, or witness marks where something struck the ring, with cracks radiating from it. A blow can also flex the ring and start a crack on the side opposite the contact point.
A blunt blow is harder to see: it leaves a full or partial ring-shaped crack just outside the spot it touched, and often little else on the surface.
A crack with a contact mark points to a ring knocked or forced home during installation, especially when it failed at the first start after a rebuild with no dry run or flush event behind it.
How to Prevent Thermal Shock
Thermal shock is prevented by keeping the temperature change at the face slow and by fitting a face material that survives the swings the pump will still see.
Operating Changes
The operating practices that prevent thermal shock keep cool liquid off a hot face and hot liquid out of a cold seal:
- Keep the faces wet: prime and vent before every start and protect the pump against running dry.
- Restore a lost flush warm: bring it back at a temperature close to the seal chamber’s, or stop the pump and let the faces cool before restoring cold flow.
- Temper the flush: in hot service, supply an external flush at a temperature near the process temperature.
- Cool down slowly: do not flush a hot pump with cold water after shutdown.
Pumps in hot service also need a controlled preheat at the rate the pump maker gives.
Start a hot-service pump only once its casing is close to the pumping temperature and has soaked there, using the pump maker’s startup figure where it gives one.
Face Material
Among common seal face materials, alumina resists thermal shock worst and silicon carbide and carbon resist it well; tungsten carbide heat-checks when lubrication is marginal.
Where lubrication is marginal or dry running is possible, pair tungsten carbide with carbon, not with silicon carbide, alumina or itself.
Alumina and silicon carbide faces are about equally strong and tough. Silicon carbide resists thermal shock better because it conducts heat several times better and expands less, so the same sudden cooling builds less stress at its surface.
A face shrink-fitted into a metal holder for hot service also needs a holder of a low-expansion iron-nickel alloy whose expansion matches the face, so the fit stays steady through temperature swings.