Thermal distortion bends seal faces out of flat: friction heat at the sealing interface makes each ring expand unevenly, the faces tilt into a shallow cone, and the gap between them closes at one edge and opens at the other. Because the fluid film between the faces is so thin, that change moves the contact onto the closed edge, raises the contact pressure and wear there, and changes the leakage.
How far the faces move is set mostly by design: pressure deforms the faces the opposite way from heat, and a seal is designed so that the two together give the faces the right shape at its operating point. Silicon carbide faces limit the thermal part through their high thermal conductivity, and a flush that reaches all the way round the faces keeps the heating even.
How Heat Bends the Faces
Heat tilts each face into a shallow cone, called thermal coning, because the running surface gets hotter than the rest of the ring and the hotter side expands more. Most of that heat is made by friction at the interface. The pumped fluid, a heating or cooling jacket, or the seal’s cooling piping also raises or lowers the average face temperature, and a faster shaft makes more friction heat and a steeper gradient, so the face tilts further out of flat.
In the usual pump seal, with process pressure at the outer diameter (OD), friction heat collects at the inner diameter (ID) while the fluid at the OD carries heat away. The faces close at the ID and open toward the OD, so the gap converges from the pressure side to the atmosphere side. Which edge closes depends on the seal’s geometry and cooling, and a seal built or cooled differently can close at the OD instead.
Heat that is uneven around the circumference also makes the faces wavy around the ring. A low-conductivity face adds local hot spots: on a high-friction face such as aluminium oxide, the heat stays at the running surface.
What Distortion Does to the Seal
Thermal distortion changes the shape of the gap the fluid film runs in, and with it the leakage, the contact pressure and the wear. In operation, distortion from pressure and heat together can easily take a seal face ten light bands or more out of flat, against the two helium light bands that face flatness specifications commonly call for.
In steady running the average film thickness follows the cone of the gap: the more the faces converge, the thicker the average film. Leakage across the faces rises with the cube of the film thickness, so a small change in taper makes a large change in leakage.
At the closed edge, contact shrinks from the full face width to a narrow band. Contact pressure peaks in that band and friction torque rises, and the local wear that follows can lead to excessive leakage and seal failure.
Distortion at Start-Up and in Upsets
At start-up and in an upset the faces are away from the shape a steadily running seal settles into, so these are the periods of higher leakage and faster wear.
At standstill, pressure and mechanical load alone shape the gap. After start-up the faces heat up and move toward their hot shape, and the face temperature lags behind the shaft speed.
A new seal leaks more at start-up than once it has worn in, particularly with hard-against-hard faces, because wearing in changes the face profiles to compensate for pressure and thermal distortion. That worn-in profile fits the conditions it wore under, and a change in load or face temperature starts a new wear transition.
The upsets that move face temperature furthest are those that take liquid away from the faces, such as a flush that has stopped working or cooling water shut off to a heat exchanger.
How to Recognise It on a Worn Face
Thermal distortion leaves contact and wear concentrated toward one edge of the face instead of a track across its full width. In the usual outside-pressurized pump seal, the face shows a heavy contact band at the ID that fades to little or no contact toward the OD. Check the seal’s design and cooling before deciding which edge the heat closed, because a seal that closes at the OD shows the band there.
That band is not the only thermal sign, and a full-circle pattern can mislead. The Fluid Sealing Association classes a continuous 360° concave or convex wear pattern as face deflection and gives only mechanical causes for it, such as poor support of the stationary face or poor hydraulic balance. Its thermal cause, improper cooling, comes under face distortion, where the wear pattern is non-uniform and can be hard to see.
To bring that uneven pattern out, polish the face lightly on a lapping plate. High spots appear at two or more points around the face.
Two other heat marks on a worn face are separate failures. Chipping at both the ID and the OD, with pitting over the whole face, points to the fluid vaporizing between the faces; radial cracks point to heat checking from friction heat or to thermal shock.