Mechanical seal MTBF is the average time between seal failures across a population of sealed pumps: the service time of the seals counted, divided by the number of seal failures among them. Plants use it to see whether seal reliability is improving, to set targets with their seal supplier, and to find the pumps whose seals fail again and again.

A site-wide seal MTBF of 60 months is a good figure by the European Sealing Association (ESA), in its 2025 reliability guide. Most of the gain toward it comes from how seals are operated and installed; a better seal design pays off on the duties that still fail once those are fixed.

Strictly, the IEC reliability vocabulary reserves MTBF for repairable items and gives a non-repairable item a mean time to failure (MTTF) instead. Plants keep the name seal MTBF because the figure tracks each pump’s sealing position, which goes back into service after every failure.

How to Calculate Seal MTBF

Divide the number of installed pumps by the number of seal failures recorded over a period, and multiply by the length of that period in months:

Seal MTBF (months) = installed pumps ÷ seal failures in the period × months in the period

With one month of data this is the plant index the seal industry uses. A longer period steadies the result on a small pump population, where one month can hold no failures or several.

Only seal failures go in the denominator.

The seal failure rate is the reciprocal of the MTBF.

What Counts as a Seal Failure

Count every seal that had to be replaced or repaired because it could no longer seal as required, and keep seals pulled while still sound out of the count.

A seal removed during planned maintenance, or replaced because a bearing failed, goes in a separate “replaced, no failure” category. Seals that reached a normal life still count as failures.

Leakage above the leak definition in the plant’s emissions regulation is a failure even while the seal keeps running. Write the plant’s definition down and apply it the same way every month.

Operating Time or Calendar Time

Use calendar time against the installed pump count, the basis of the seal industry’s plant index, and state that basis next to every figure you report.

Calendar time counts the months a spared pump stood idle, so a site with many standby pumps reports a higher calendar MTBF than its running seals achieve. Either basis works, provided every figure you compare against uses the same one.

What Is a Good Seal MTBF

Sixty months is a good site-wide seal MTBF: the ESA calls it the benchmark most sites want to reach, and notes that the figure varies by industry.

Seal MTBF benchmarks and targets (months)
Target set by some major operators
100 months
Good benchmark for most sites
60 months
Acceptable in midstream (counted on operating time)
48 months
API 682 design target (25,000 h)
34 months

API 682’s 25,000 hours is often quoted as the life a seal should reach. It was the design target behind the standard’s default seal selections, never a performance guarantee.

Neither figure is an average seal lifespan: the life of an individual seal depends on its duty.

Why Plant Figures Do Not Compare

Seal MTBF figures from two plants compare only when both count the same events as failures on the same time base for similar duties, and that is rarely the case:

  • Failure date: some plants date a failure when the work order is written, others when the pump is taken out of service and sent to the repair shop.
  • Leak limit: a plant under a tighter emissions rule counts leaking seals as failures that another plant would leave running.
  • Duty: high-temperature, low-specific-gravity, low-vapour-margin and abrasive services make any target harder, and seal lives in chemical plants are generally put at 50% to 60% of refinery values.
  • Era: plants in the mid-1990s reported seal MTBF of around 70 months, above today’s 60-month benchmark, because emissions rules have since tightened what counts as failed.

The figure that does compare is your own plant’s, month on month, counted the same way throughout.

How to Improve Seal MTBF

Seal MTBF rises most when a plant fixes how its seals are operated and installed, because that is where most premature seal failures start: operations caused 49% of premature seal failures in ESA records of 3,500 pump failures at 18 end users in the 2020s.

Root cause of premature seal failures, 3,500 failures at 18 end users, 2020s (%)
49 %Operations
28 %Maintenance
23 %Engineering

Sort the failures by seal life before choosing a fix. In one process plant’s seal records studied in 1992, the seals failing within 5,000 hours traced to fitting and alignment, and better face materials and seal selection left their share near 50%.

Find the Bad Actors

Rank the pumps by seal failures over the review period, take the worst 10 to 15, and for each one decide whether the cause lies in the seal, the pump or the process before anything is changed.

Keep the old seal and photograph the teardown. Check the shop records for a recent change of seal design, flush plan or impeller that may already have removed the failure mode.

The failed faces and parts usually hold the only evidence of how the seal was run:

  • Torn or broken O-rings: installation damage.
  • Thermal cracks, chipped faces or blued metal parts: dry running.
  • Broken or corroded springs, attacked elastomers: chemical incompatibility.

Correct the Operating Conditions

Start by checking the seal’s actual operating conditions against its data sheet: pumping temperature, vapour pressure, specific gravity, and suction and discharge pressure.

Then look for the conditions that run the faces dry or starve them of liquid: flow far from the design point, cavitation, closed valves, poor priming, a lost flush and process upsets.

Clean and check the flush, quench and cooling lines every time a seal is changed.

Fix Installation and Alignment

Fix the installation errors that make seals fail within weeks of fitting: incorrect seal compression, seal faces not square to the shaft, and the misalignment, run-out or vibration a pump passes to its seal.

Incorrect compression is the easiest of these to remove. A cartridge seal is set before it reaches the pump, so the fitter cannot over- or under-compress the springs.

Shaft run-out, bearing condition, the base plate and venting belong on the overhaul checklist.

Match the Seal to the Duty

When a duty’s seals still fail after they are run and fitted correctly, change the seal to one built for that duty:

  • Face pair: on duties prone to dry running or poor lubrication, silicon carbide or tungsten carbide running against carbon tolerates the heat far better than ceramic or stellite faces.
  • Arrangement: where the process fluid lubricates poorly, crystallises or is hazardous, a double seal with a barrier fluid lets the faces run on a clean liquid chosen for them.
  • Balance: on higher-pressure duties, a balanced seal lowers the closing force on the faces and the heat they generate.