Pump vibration destroys a mechanical seal by moving the two seal faces against each other until the fluid film between them breaks down: the faces then strike and rub, which wears, chips and cracks them, while the same motion frets the dynamic O-ring, fatigues bellows welds and wears the drive.
A better-selected seal tolerates more vibration, but the Fluid Sealing Association ranks removing the source as the more reliable fix: misalignment, worn bearings, impeller imbalance, cavitation, and running the pump away from its best efficiency point.
How Vibration Reaches the Seal Faces
Vibration reaches the faces through the shaft and the pump housing and moves the rotating face and the stationary face relative to each other. That relative motion disturbs the fluid film that normally keeps the faces apart. Worn bearings and wear rings make it worse: the extra radial clearance lets the shaft whip, and the whip is carried into the seal area.
Axial vibration does not stay axial at the seal. The flexibly mounted face responds to a push along the shaft by tilting as well, so the gap opens on one side and closes on the other. In a liquid seal the film cannot compress to absorb a sudden axial push, so the faces take the extra load directly and can come into hard contact.
Once the film breaks down, the faces hit each other. Each impact puts a tensile stress into the face, and that stress repeats at running speed and grows fatigue cracks.
What Vibration Does to the Faces
Vibration wears and chips the seal faces and starts fatigue cracks in them. The damage shows as a wear track, chips where the impacts land and heat marks, and it looks different on each face material. Most face materials are brittle, so impacts can fracture a face as well as chip it.
Bearings failing alongside the seal point to vibration, a pattern a US Department of Energy report on long-shaft slurry pumps traced to shaft vibration. Without that pattern, work through the other causes of mechanical seal failure first.
What Vibration Does to the Rest of the Seal
Outside the faces, vibration damages the parts that let the floating face follow the rotating one and the parts that carry torque:
- Dynamic O-ring: it frets against its sealing surface until the flexibly mounted seal ring no longer moves freely along the shaft to keep the faces closed.
- Metal bellows: the welds of a metal bellows seal flex with every vibration cycle and fail by fatigue.
- Drive pins and lugs: they wear, and so do the slots, grooves or holes they sit in; the loose drive lets the seal ring lose its axial tracking and damages the rings.
- Drive collar set screws: they loosen, and the collar stops transmitting torque to the rotating parts of the seal.
A seal ring that cannot follow the shaft leaves the faces open, so a seal can leak from vibration even when the faces themselves came out undamaged.