Metal bellows seals fail in chemical service in four ways: the thin bellows plates and their welds corrode or crack from fatigue, deposits pack the convolutions so the bellows stops moving, pressure or drive torque beyond the rating deforms the plates, or the faces fail for reasons the bellows has no part in.
Corrosion of the Bellows Plates and Welds
Corrosion breaks a bellows sooner than a solid seal part because the plates are thin and the welds joining them are the least resistant metal in the seal.
Chloride Stress Corrosion Cracking
Chloride stress corrosion cracking cracks a stainless bellows when chlorides, tensile stress and heat meet, and a bellows always carries tensile stress because it is a compressed spring. The austenitic stainless steels are the most susceptible family, and standard 304/304L and 316/316L are very susceptible.
AM350, a common standard bellows alloy, sits close to that group.
Chloride levels that crack stainless are low. Fully immersed stainless steel rarely cracks below 60 °C (150 °F), but failures have been reported at chloride levels as low as 10 ppm. Where fluid evaporates, a few ppm of chloride in the bulk can concentrate to hundreds of ppm.
A seal face is a heat-rejecting surface and the atmospheric side of a seal is a wet/dry interface, the concentrating conditions under which low chloride levels crack stainless. Nickel alloys such as C-276 and 625 resist far better.
Pitting and Weld Corrosion
Pitting and weld corrosion perforate a bellows by attacking small spots instead of the whole surface: a pit breaks down the passive layer at one point and grows through the plate, and the weld zone corrodes faster than the plate around it. Chlorides and other halides drive pitting of stainless steel, and higher chloride content, higher temperature and lower pH all make it worse. Common chloride sources in chemical plants include hydrochloric acid and hypochlorite bleach.
Welding heat can sensitize standard stainless steel by drawing chromium out of the grain boundaries, leaving a narrow strip along the weld that corrodes faster than the plate. Low-carbon L grades resist sensitization during welding, but not long service in the sensitizing range of 950 to 1450 °F.
Nickel-alloy bellows are not immune. Even C-276 weld metal corrodes faster than the wrought plate it joins. Hydrofluoric acid corrodes C-276 at a measurable rate, and HF can also attack nickel alloys internally, below the surface.
Fatigue Cracking
A bellows cracks from fatigue because every pressure swing and every bit of axial or angular movement flexes its plates, and plates flexed over and over eventually crack, even below their elastic limit.
Where Fatigue Cracks Start
A fatigue crack in a welded seal bellows starts in the vicinity of a weld, and on a bellows pressurized from the outside it typically starts at the ID welds.
Some pages say cracks start at the roots or crowns of the convolutions. That describes formed metal bellows expansion joints in ducting, where circumferential cracks at roots or crowns are the usual fatigue failure.
What Drives Bellows Fatigue
Shaft movement, vibration, misalignment and pressure or thermal cycling drive bellows fatigue, because each adds flex cycles beyond what the bellows was designed to take up:
- Shaft movement: end play, thermal growth, impeller adjustment and face wear all move the bellows, and a stiff bellows has less margin to take them up.
- Vibration: harmonic vibration, often set off by dry running, flutters the plates, and many bellows have no vibration damper.
- Misalignment and runout: a bent shaft or an off-square gland makes the bellows flex once per revolution. Check it before installing with a shaft runout measurement.
- Pressure and thermal cycling: batch processes that swing pressure or temperature flex the bellows on each cycle.
Deposits That Lock the Convolutions
Solids, crystals or coke between the plates make a bellows seal leak because the bellows can no longer flex evenly, so it stops pushing the faces together and the faces open. Caustic near its solubility limit is a common case: it precipitates onto the plates and distorts the seal.
The risk is highest on stationary bellows and on pumps that sit idle for long periods, when deposits build up undisturbed. A rotating bellows tends to throw solids out of the convolutions, which is why rotating designs suit high-concentration caustic. In hot hydrocarbon or polymer service, coke and solidified product pack the convolutions the same way.
Pressure and Torque Beyond the Bellows Rating
A bellows run above its pressure rating deforms its plates permanently, and a deformed bellows no longer holds the faces at the right load. Reverse pressure is a separate rating: in a dual pressurized arrangement, pressure from the wrong side can distort the bellows even when the forward rating is met.
Above its torque limit, the bellows twists. The bellows transmits drive torque from the set-screw collar to the rotating face, so a fluid that thickens or solidifies on the faces loads the bellows at every start-up. Makers use double-ply bellows for this duty.
Installation Errors
A wrong setting length, plates damaged in handling and setting clips left in place shorten a bellows seal’s life, because each loads the thin plates before the pump even runs:
- Wrong setting length: compressing the bellows too much raises plate stress and fatigue; too little lets the faces open. Follow the seal setting compression on the drawing.
- Damaged plates: a dent or nick from handling, or from sliding the seal over keyways and threads, becomes the start of a crack.
- Setting clips left in place: the clips that hold a cartridge seal’s length must come off after the gland and collar are tightened; left on, they stop the bellows following the shaft.
Face Failures the Bellows Cannot Prevent
The failures of a bellows seal that start at the faces are dry running, flashing of fluid between the faces, thermal cracking and product sticking the faces together.
- Dry running: starting a pump before a double seal is pressurized, or running it with the suction closed, burns the faces.
- Vaporization: a fluid near its boiling point flashes between the faces, and the faces chatter and chip.
- Thermal cracking: a sudden temperature change cracks a ceramic face.
- Sticky product: product that bonds the faces together raises torque on the drive pin and cracks the stationary face from the pin slot.
How to Tell Which Failure Mode Broke the Seal
The failed seal shows its failure mode in where the damage sits: find which component carries it, then class the damage as chemical, mechanical or thermal. A seal has three groups of parts to check: the faces, the secondary seals, and the hardware that holds the faces together, which on a bellows seal includes the bellows itself.
- Crack in the bellows: corrosion cracking and fatigue look alike to the eye and differ under a microscope, so a cracked bellows needs a metallurgical section. On that section, narrow branched cracks running across the grains usually point to chloride stress corrosion cracking, and cracks along the grain boundaries usually point to a sensitized weld zone. Beach marks point to fatigue; a crack starting at a weld fits either mode.
- Pinholes along a weld line: pitting at the weld, which can also start chloride cracks.
- Deposits between the plates: crystals or coke packed into the convolutions, often with uneven plate spacing, point to locked convolutions.
- Damaged faces with a sound bellows: a face failure; read the face marks with our guide to reading seal face damage.
Read the clues together. A cracked stationary face with sticky residue on it points to product adhesion; the same crack with no residue more likely came from impact during installation. Do not judge a crack by the size of the leak either: chloride cracks branch and fill with corrosion product, so a small leak can come from a large crack.