A PTFE bellows seal is the pick for an acid pump when the acid is too aggressive for any affordable bellows alloy and the duty stays cool. A metal bellows seal is the pick when the duty runs hotter, or when the acid is hazardous enough to need a dual seal, provided its bellows alloy has been checked against that acid’s concentration and temperature.

What Is a PTFE Bellows Seal

A PTFE bellows seal is a non-pusher seal whose bellows is made of PTFE.

What Is a Metal Bellows Seal

A metal bellows seal uses a stack of thin metal diaphragms, welded at the inner and outer edges, as its spring, its drive and its secondary seal all at once.

The bellows alloys used in chemical pumps are few:

  • 316 stainless steel: easy to weld and common in general-duty bellows, and resistant to many acids at the right concentration and temperature.
  • Alloy C-276: widely used for welded bellows, suited to many acids and strong oxidizers, and corrosion resistant in its weld zones.
  • Alloy 20: developed for hot sulfuric acid, and used only when the common alloys are not acceptable.
  • Alloy 400: the usual bellows alloy for hydrofluoric acid.

The Difference Between PTFE and Metal Bellows Seals

A PTFE bellows seal resists almost any acid but is limited to cool duty, while a metal bellows seal handles higher temperatures and can be built into a dual seal, but resists an acid only where its alloy suits it. The two differ on four points: acid resistance, temperature, failure mode and dual-seal capability.

Acid Resistance

A PTFE bellows resists practically every acid a pump will see at any concentration, while a metal bellows resists an acid only inside a range of concentration and temperature set by its alloy.

Bellows plates are thin, so a corrosion rate that would be acceptable on a pump casing can perforate a bellows. Haynes’ laboratory data for C-276 show 0.46 mm per year in 10 % hydrochloric acid at 66 °C, rising to 1.18 mm per year at 79 °C.

Compare every alloy’s corrosion rate with the bellows plate thickness. 316 should not be used where chlorides are high because it pits, and Alloy 400 in hydrofluoric acid corrodes much faster in vapour or with oxygen present. Check the bellows alloy against the actual acid, concentration and temperature on our chemical compatibility chart before you choose the metal.

Temperature Limit

A metal bellows seal runs much hotter than a PTFE bellows seal. Check the temperature rating in the PTFE seal’s own data sheet against your liquid temperature.

PTFE as a material is usually limited to below 500 °F (260 °C), so vendor pages that give 260 °C for a PTFE bellows seal are quoting the resin’s limit. In acid service, the corrosion rate of the bellows alloy climbs with temperature and usually sets the working limit well before the seal’s rating does.

How Each One Fails

A PTFE bellows usually fails by creep and loss of face load, and a metal bellows by corrosion and cracking of its thin plates.

Use in a Dual Seal

A metal bellows seal can be built into a dual seal for hazardous acid.

A dual seal is called for when the acid is toxic or hazardous, or must not escape to atmosphere for any other reason. If your acid duty needs one, choose a metal bellows seal.

How to Choose the Right One

Choose a PTFE bellows seal when the acid itself is the problem and the duty is otherwise mild; choose a metal bellows seal when temperature takes the duty past PTFE’s limits or the duty needs a dual seal, and a bellows alloy is proven for the acid. Each of these conditions points one way:

  • The acid attacks every bellows alloy you would consider: PTFE bellows, as long as the duty also fits its other limits.
  • Liquid hotter than the PTFE seal’s temperature rating: metal bellows.
  • Toxic or hazardous acid that needs a dual seal: metal bellows.

When neither bellows fits, use a sealless magnetic drive pump.