A purpose-made synthetic barrier fluid, usually based on polyalphaolefin (PAO), outperforms mineral oil in a double mechanical seal: it holds its viscosity better as temperature changes, resists oxidation, and comes without the additive package that fouls seal faces, at a higher cost. Mineral oil still works when it is a high-purity paraffinic oil with few or no additives and a low viscosity grade.
The viscosity grade you pick and the additives in the oil matter more than whether the base stock is synthetic or mineral.
What Is Synthetic Oil Barrier Fluid
A synthetic oil barrier fluid is a lubricant made from a synthesized base stock, usually PAO, and formulated specifically for the barrier or buffer side of a dual seal.
PAO fluids can also be formulated for applications that require FDA compliance.
What Is Mineral Oil Barrier Fluid
A mineral oil barrier fluid is a petroleum lubricant, cut from crude oil in the refinery’s lubricating-oil range, used in the seal pot in place of a purpose-made fluid. In practice that means a hydraulic oil, a gear or bearing oil, or a turbine oil the plant already stocks. Mineral base oils are either paraffinic or naphthenic.
The Difference Between Synthetic and Mineral Oil Barrier Fluid
Synthetic barrier fluid is ahead of mineral oil on viscosity stability and freedom from deposits, and behind it on price.
Low-Temperature Behaviour
PAO has a higher viscosity index than refined mineral oil, so it thickens less as it cools.
Check the oil at the coldest condition the seal will see, usually start-up or stand-by with an outdoor reservoir, rather than at running temperature. If it is too thick there, use a lighter grade or heat the seal piping during stand-by.
Oxidation and Deposits
PAO barrier fluids have good resistance to oxidation and thermal breakdown. At the seal faces, though, the larger difference comes from additives. Lube oils carry anti-wear and oxidation-inhibitor packages designed for gearboxes, hydraulics and turbines, and in a seal those additives can plate out on the faces. Purpose-made barrier fluids are usually supplied with no additives at all.
Cost
Synthetic barrier fluid costs more than an industrial mineral lube oil. The difference is felt most on a plant with a large Plan 54 system or many dual seals to fill.
Much of the extra cost comes back in service. One synthetic grade can often cover most of the dual seals in a plant, and its stability may stretch the time between fluid changes.
How to Choose the Right One
Use a purpose-made, low-viscosity synthetic barrier fluid as the default. Use mineral oil only if it is a high-purity paraffinic oil with minimal or no additives and a low viscosity grade, and keep turbine oils, automatic transmission fluids and additive-laden hydraulic oils out of the seal pot.
Choose the lowest viscosity that suits the duty; higher-viscosity synthetics suit hot pumps and low shaft speeds. With a carbon face, keep the barrier fluid’s viscosity low to avoid blistering the carbon, or change to a hard-against-hard pair such as silicon carbide against silicon carbide.
Barrier fluid that crosses the inner seal into the process must not react with it or contaminate product downstream. PAO is compatible with most processes, and a fluid with a proven record in the same service is the safer pick; where no oil is acceptable in the product, look at water or glycol as the barrier fluid instead.