Yes, an unbalanced mechanical seal can be replaced with a balanced one in the same pump, as long as the shaft or sleeve under the new seal has the step that balance requires or the new seal is a metal bellows seal.

A balanced seal has a balance ratio below 1, typically 0.6 to 0.9. The change is worth making where seal chamber pressure, speed, temperature or a light liquid overloads the unbalanced faces. On a cool, low-pressure duty the unbalanced seal leaks less and is the one to keep.

When the Upgrade Is Worth It

The upgrade is worth it when the unbalanced seal fails because its faces carry too much load for the duty, so they run hot and wear before a stable liquid film can form between them.

The failed seal usually shows whether face load is the cause. Fast carbon wear, heat discoloration or heat checking on the hard face, and a seal that fails at about the same short interval each time point to face load. Chipped faces, a broken spring or a seal that leaks from the first day point to causes a balanced seal will not cure.

Changing to stiffer or softer springs does not replace balance at high pressure.

Seal Chamber Pressure

The general rule is to use a balanced seal when seal chamber pressure is above 200 psi (1,380 kPa, or 13.8 bar).

The pressure to judge by is the seal chamber’s, which is not the discharge pressure. Calculate or measure the seal chamber pressure before comparing it with the rule.

Heat, Speed and Light Fluids

Shaft speed, temperature and a light, volatile liquid can each call for a balanced seal below 200 psi seal chamber pressure, because each makes the liquid film between the faces harder to keep.

The heat generated at the faces scales with face pressure times sliding velocity, the PV value, and a PV of 200,000 psi-ft/min is often used as the upper guide for applying industrial unbalanced seals.

On temperature, the duty to watch is a hot liquid with little margin to its boiling point, hot water included.

For light hydrocarbons, a 1970s edition of API 610 required a balanced seal for any liquid with a specific gravity below 0.65 at stuffing box temperature, such as propane and butane, whatever the sealing pressure.

When to Keep the Unbalanced Seal

Keep the unbalanced seal on a low-pressure, moderate-speed, cool, non-volatile duty where the seal already lasts until its faces wear out. On that duty a balanced seal gains nothing and adds leakage, a risk of face separation, and cost.

What Has to Change in the Pump

The pump has to provide a step under a new pusher seal, because every balanced pusher seal needs a shoulder on the shaft or on a sleeve so that its faces can reach below the diameter its secondary seal seals on. The three options are:

  • Cartridge seal: a balanced cartridge seal comes with its own sleeve, gland and collar, and the step is on that sleeve, so the pump shaft stays as it is.
  • Component seal on a stepped sleeve: a sleeve stepped to the new seal’s drawing replaces the plain sleeve. Where the old seal sat on the bare shaft, the shaft has to be stepped or replaced with one that takes a sleeve.
  • Metal bellows seal: a metal bellows seal is balanced by the bellows itself, so it can run on the plain shaft without a step.

The seal chamber has to take the new seal too. Stuffing boxes sized for packing often leave too little radial room between shaft and bore for a cartridge seal, and the cartridge gland has to fit the chamber face and its studs. The new seal’s assembly drawing shows any rework the pump needs, so check it before the pump is opened.

What to Check Before Ordering

Before ordering the balanced seal, confirm that the old seal is unbalanced, then check the fit dimensions, the pump’s condition and the duty:

  • That the old seal is unbalanced: a pusher seal on a plain shaft with no shoulder at the seal is unbalanced. One that already sits on a step is balanced.
  • The fit dimensions: shaft or sleeve diameter, seal chamber bore and depth, gland pilot, stud diameter and bolt pattern, and the distance to the first obstruction outside the chamber.
  • The pump’s condition: shaft runout, end play, the squareness of the chamber face to the shaft, and the concentricity of the chamber bore.
  • The duty: seal chamber pressure, temperature, speed, the liquid (specific gravity, vapor pressure, solids, corrosiveness) and the old seal’s failure history.

To build the balanced replacement, we need the old seal’s drawing, its model or part number, or the seal itself as a sample, together with the duty and the dimensions above. Photos of the failed faces help.

What a Balanced Seal Will Not Fix

A balanced seal fixes only a seal design that does not suit the duty’s pressure, temperature, speed or liquid; every other cause of seal failure remains after the change:

  • A pump in poor condition: shaft runout, deflection, vibration or worn bearings.
  • How the pump is run: cavitation, dry running at start-up, or a flush or cooling system that has stopped working.
  • Abrasive or corrosive liquid: solids or chemical attack wear the faces and other seal parts at any face load.
  • Handling and installation errors: faces chipped, scratched or dirtied before fitting, a wrong seal setting, or components placed wrongly in the chamber.
  • Too little vapor margin: a balanced seal lowers face heat, but it cannot make up for a seal chamber pressure that sits too close to the liquid’s vapor pressure.