To upgrade a pump seal from carbon to silicon carbide faces, first confirm from the worn carbon face and the service that a hard face will cure the failure, then choose the face pairing and the silicon carbide grade, check that the seal and its flush can carry a hard face, and fit and start the new faces with more care than carbon needed. Carbon is self-lubricating and silicon carbide is not, so a seal that gives up its carbon face depends entirely on the liquid film between the faces.

Step 1: Confirm Silicon Carbide Will Solve the Problem

Silicon carbide fixes a carbon-faced seal when the carbon failed because it was too soft or too flexible for the service, and makes things worse when it failed because the liquid film between the faces was too thin.

Read the Worn Carbon Face

The worn carbon face shows which kind of failure you have, so read the damage on it before ordering anything.

  • Blisters: raised, shiny spots on the carbon, or the pits left where they broke away. They come from viscous fluids shearing the carbon, from light hydrocarbons that vaporize inside its pores, and from thermal cycling.
  • Scoring from particles: grooves cut by solids in the fluid that are harder than carbon.
  • Even wear with no blisters or particle damage, in a thin or hot fluid: the faces were running on a marginal film. Carbon was the right material there, and a hard pair will fare worse.

Services That Justify Silicon Carbide

Silicon carbide pays off in services that cut, blister or distort carbon.

  • Abrasives and high solids: where hard particles are present, both faces need to be a hard material.
  • Viscous fluids: high shear between the faces raises blisters on the carbon, so two hard faces are the usual choice in thicker fluids. An antimony-impregnated carbon grade also resists blistering and keeps a self-lubricating face, so it is worth trying first where blisters are the only damage.
  • High pressure: a carbon face loses flatness under pressure that a silicon carbide face holds.

Change for chemical attack only when the carbon grade itself is being attacked, and then to a silicon carbide grade that resists the fluid (Step 3).

Services Where Carbon Should Stay

Keep carbon wherever the faces run on a thin, hot or interrupted film: low-viscosity fluids, liquids that vaporize between the faces, hot water, slow pumps at low pressure, and any pump that may run dry.

For hot water the usual cure is a hot-water carbon grade against a hard face, with the water kept cool and above its vapor pressure at the faces (Step 5).

Step 2: Choose the Face Pairing

Run silicon carbide against carbon unless the service is abrasive, viscous or high-pressure enough to need two hard faces; choose silicon carbide against silicon carbide only where the fluid keeps a full liquid film between the faces at all times.

Check what the carbon ran against before ordering. The mating face of a carbon seal is almost always a hard material, often silicon carbide already, so replacing the carbon ring with silicon carbide turns a soft-against-hard pair into a hard-against-hard one, which the service has to allow (Step 1). When the carbon ran against a ceramic seat, a silicon carbide seat against the existing carbon is an upgrade that keeps the self-lubricating face.

In crystallizing fluids, carbon can stay if the seal has the process fluid at its outside diameter and an external quench under API Plan 62 washes crystals off the atmospheric side; without a quench, choose two hard faces.

Step 3: Choose the Silicon Carbide Grade

Choose sintered silicon carbide for caustics, other high-pH fluids and strong acids; elsewhere, sintered or reaction-bonded silicon carbide will both serve.

For two silicon carbide faces in a service where lubrication is marginal, graphite-loaded silicon carbide grades add a softer graphite phase that lowers friction. Whatever the grade, check the elastomers and metal parts of the seal against the fluid at the same time as the new face.

Step 4: Check That the Seal Accepts Silicon Carbide Faces

The seal accepts a silicon carbide ring when its drawing or its maker lists one for that seal; a silicon carbide ring cut to the carbon ring’s dimensions is not a drop-in substitute. Three things differ between the two rings even at the same size.

  • Stiffness: under pressure, a carbon ring deflects much more than a silicon carbide ring of the same shape, so carbon rings are made with larger cross-sections to stay flat, and each ring is sized for its own material.
  • Mounting: silicon carbide is brittle and chips or fractures under mechanical stress or shock, so it is often fitted in a metal holder, and a rotating silicon carbide face sometimes carries a metal shroud on its outside diameter.
  • Drive: a silicon carbide ring needs a robust drive so it does not hang up on the softer metal parts of the seal retainer.

Some seal makers sell the same seal with either pair under different material codes. If the code or drawing lists a silicon carbide version, order that one. If the seal will run in a service other than the one it was selected for, ask the maker before fitting it.

When the maker offers no silicon carbide version, or the seal is obsolete, we build a seal with silicon carbide faces from the seal’s drawing, its model or part number, or the old seal itself as a sample.

Step 5: Check the Flush and Dry-Run Protection

Once the seal runs silicon carbide faces, the flush and the system around it must keep liquid between the faces whenever the shaft turns, because neither face of a hard pair is self-lubricating.

The flush has to deliver liquid to the faces at a temperature, pressure and cleanliness that let it cool and lubricate them. Turn it on before start-up and make sure no valve in the line can shut it off by mistake.

A general rule for seal chamber pressure is a margin of at least 175 kPa (25 psi) above the liquid’s vapor pressure. A pump that cannot hold that margin, or whose product is too dirty or hot to flush its own seal, needs a different flush plan, such as clean liquid injected from outside under API Plan 32.

If a pump with two silicon carbide faces can lose its liquid, from a sump that empties, a closed suction valve or a tank that runs low, protect it with a low-flow or dry-run trip, or keep carbon in the pair.

Step 6: Install the New Faces

Install silicon carbide faces by the normal seal installation steps, with extra care for a brittle ring, clean dry faces and the seal maker’s runout limit.

Handle the silicon carbide ring so it takes no knocks. Wipe both lapped faces clean and dry with a lint-free cloth and a quick-drying solvent, and put no lubricant on them unless the seal drawing calls for it. Torque the gland bolts evenly so the gland does not cock.

Silicon carbide faces need no tighter shaft runout limit than the one the seal maker sets for the seal. Check your own seal’s figure and measure the runout before fitting.

If the new face changes the seat, take the seal setting from the new seat’s dimensions.

Step 7: Start Up and Run In the New Faces

Start the pump only with the seal chamber full and vented and the flush running, then expect the new hard faces to leak more at first and settle as they wear in.

  1. Turn the shaft by hand: confirm it rotates freely after assembly.
  2. Check the flush and cooling lines: they should be open and unobstructed, with the flush on before the motor starts.
  3. Fill and vent: prime the pump and vent air and vapor from the casing and the seal chamber.

A squealing noise from the seal area means the faces are running dry: stop the pump and find the cause before restarting. Repeat the three checks above after every shutdown, as well as after the change.