O-rings in mechanical seals fail from compression set, chemical attack and swelling, temperatures outside the compound’s limits, extrusion into a clearance gap, hang-up of the dynamic O-ring, abrasion and fretting, and damage during installation, often more than one at once. Each cause leaves its own evidence on the ring: a flattened cross-section, swelling, cracks, a nibbled edge, a worn band or a clean cut.
When the leak comes from the faces, the springs or the pump itself rather than from an O-ring, the wider list of reasons for mechanical seal failure applies.
Compression Set
Compression set makes a seal O-ring fail by leaving it permanently flattened: after long squeeze, usually at heat, the rubber no longer springs back, so its contact force against the shaft, sleeve or gland bore fades until the joint leaks. The leak often shows first at a cold start or after a shutdown.
On the bench, the ring has flat faces where it touched the groove and the mating surface, and its cross-section stays flat, close to square, after removal.
Replace every O-ring when the seal is rebuilt. If the set came early, choose a compound rated for set resistance at the temperature the O-ring actually sees, which near the faces is higher than the product temperature.
Chemical Attack and Swelling
The sealed fluid, the flush or the barrier fluid changes the rubber of a seal O-ring itself: it either swells and softens the ring, or draws ingredients out of it so the ring shrinks and hardens.
On the bench, look for a ring that is larger, soft, sticky or blistered, or one that is smaller, hard and cracked. Laying it beside an unused ring from the same kit makes the change obvious.
Check the compound against every fluid the O-ring touches, which is more than the product. In a dual seal the O-rings also sit in the barrier or buffer fluid, and the two fluids mix.
Hot water and steam reverse the usual choice between FKM and EPDM. The Fluid Sealing Association does not recommend fluoroelastomers (FKM) for water service above 70 °C (160 °F), and FKM O-rings can degrade severely in steam. EPDM is the usual secondary seal for steam service, but EPDM is not compatible with hydrocarbons.
Temperature Damage
High temperature hardens a seal O-ring: past the compound’s upper limit the rubber loses its elasticity, takes a set and cracks. Low temperature stiffens it until it can no longer follow the movement it is meant to seal.
A ring overheated by a loss of flush or by dry running is hard, cracked on the side facing the faces, and may snap when bent. Below its lower limit, the seal can leak at startup until it warms.
Fine surface cracks on a spare O-ring that has never run point to storage: ozone and sunlight crack stored rubber.
Extrusion and Nibbling
Extrusion is pressure forcing part of a seal O-ring into the clearance gap on its low-pressure side, where the edge is pinched and torn away a little at a time. In a mechanical seal those gaps are the radial clearances beside each O-ring groove: sleeve to shaft, stationary seat to gland bore, and the sliding face to its holder or sleeve.
The damaged ring shows a frayed or nibbled lip along its low-pressure side, sometimes with a thin flap of rubber still attached. A gap opened by wear or run-out, or a ring already softened by heat or swollen by the fluid, extrudes at pressures the seal handled when it was new.
The fixes act on the ring or on the gap:
- Harder compound: a higher-durometer O-ring resists being pushed into the gap at high pressure or temperature.
- Backup ring: a PEEK ring fitted behind the O-ring on the low-pressure side bridges the gap and raises the pressure the seal can hold.
- Restored clearance: a sleeve, seat or holder worn past its drawing size is replaced so the gap closes again.
Hang-Up
Hang-up is the dynamic O-ring of a pusher seal sticking on the shaft or sleeve, so the flexibly mounted face can no longer move axially to follow its mating face, and the faces separate and leak. The O-ring stops sliding when the surface under it is fretted, when deposits build up around it, or when the fluid swells it.
Deposits can form on either side of the seal. On the process side, a fluid that solidifies accumulates around the inboard dynamic O-ring and locks it. On the atmospheric side, leakage that flashes across the faces leaves dissolved minerals behind, and the crust grows until the O-ring cannot move; a steam quench, API Plan 62, keeps those solids from building up.
A hung-up O-ring can look sound on the bench, so read what surrounds it: deposits packed against the ring, a face that will not move freely by hand before teardown, or a leak that began after a shutdown and never stopped.
When hang-up keeps coming back, remove the sliding O-ring altogether: a welded metal bellows seal has no dynamic secondary seal to hang up.
Abrasion and Fretting
Abrasion wears the dynamic O-ring’s own contact surface, and fretting wears the shaft or sleeve under it; both end with an O-ring that can no longer seal or slide on its track. Abrasion comes from solids in the fluid that work between the ring and the sleeve each time it moves. The ring shows a flat, dull, scored band on its inside diameter.
Fretting comes from small cyclic axial movement as the shaft rotates, so the O-ring rubs back and forth on the same narrow band every revolution. That band turns into a dull, worn ring on the sleeve at the O-ring position.
Vibration drives fretting. Fix the vibration first, and replace a fretted sleeve along with the O-ring.
Installation Damage
Installation cuts, twists, overstretches or contaminates a seal O-ring on the way onto the shaft, and the leak usually appears on the first startup.
- Cuts and nicks: sharp edges on keyways, threads, set-screw holes and shaft shoulders slice the ring as it passes, leaving a clean cut or a peeled strip at one spot. Cover them with tape or a thin plastic sleeve before the seal slides on.
- Twisting: a ring pushed dry along the shaft drags, rolls in its groove and seats twisted.
- Wrong lubricant: petroleum grease used to slide the seal on damages an EPDM ring. Use a water-soluble lubricant, or one the O-ring compound is rated for.
- Wrong compound: a ring of the wrong compound from a kit goes in unnoticed and then fails by chemical attack or heat. Check the compound before fitting.
- Wrong size: a ring stretched over a diameter larger than it was made for thins its cross-section and loses squeeze, and an oversized ring bunches in the groove.